But still, I'm happy to get my duck on once in a while and I DO find many aspects of waterfowl completely intriguing. So, with that, I was happy to review this book from PUP. Let's get started...
I mentioned the heft of the book. Indeed, it's not a small book but you wouldn't expect it to be considering it's 600+ pages loaded with 650+ color photos, 85 color maps, and 72 color plates. You'll note that this ISN'T A FIELD GUIDE; I'd consider this more of a reference guide of types (but by all means, use it how you will).
The layout of the book is pretty straightforward; after the introduction with all the usual stuff like "how to use this book", basic anatomy of birds, and a wealth of other intro material, you come to the plates section. There you'll find color plates on the right with the corresponding plate information on the left. Here's a quick example with the white-fronted geese as a show-and-tell:
(I might insert here, rather sheepishly, that my photos of the pages look quite yellow due to the artificial light I was using. Keep that in mind as you continue reading.)
Anyway, here's a closer look at a plate example, this time using a rowdy hoard of bean geese (and pink-foots) as our subjects:
If the species shows little subspecies variation, the plate selection will be pretty basic. However, sometimes they go a bit further when you go farther (turning the page might yield another set of plates). For example, here's an additional page of the bean goose morass continued from the account you saw above, this time with more examples of bill variations:
Seriously though, I'm pretty impressed by these plates. They include a lot of detail, way more than you'd find in your typical field guide. The author could have chosen to include fewer illustrations but I like the fact that he went the other way.
Although when you turn the page and find more on this complex, I noted he left out close-up illustrations of races like B. h. leucopareia, a favorite of mine from California:
Here's a plate devoted to the white geese:
I said it though... the "h" word. I'm happy to bring that up though because this books really excels in its coverage of hybrids. Here's a delightful plate full of identification horror, a right mess:
Think you can figure out the parents of those hybrids? Take another look and then compare it to the corresponding text below:
This book covers the Aythya genus better than any others I've seen. Plate 43 is the 2nd of 3 plates that deals with Canvasback/Redhead/Common Pochard. But you'll note below that most of the illustrations on this plate are devoted to known hybrid pairings:
* Plumages (adult male: definitive basic plumage, definitive alternate plumage. Adult female: definitive basic plumage, definitive alternate plumage. Juvenile: first basic plumage, first-winter male, first winter female)
* Geographic variation
* Measurements and mass (wing chord, culmen, tail, mass in autumn/winter, tarsus, Europe vs. North America, where applicable)
* Hybridization (descriptions of all known pairings)
* Range and population
Besides all that info, the author continues by including a photographs section after the aforementioned text. Here's a quick look at the photos from the bean-geese complex:
Did I mention the section on captivity present in each species account? This book is the first I've seen that talks about prices of birds! Check out this example from a species (which I've since forgotten):
I can only guess they REALLY meant to say "... low, LOW prices! Shop and save today!" But seriously, I'm glad they're considering this aspect and including these details because issues of nasty origin are all-too-common with vagrant waterfowl.
You'll see that most of the species account is text before coming to the photo section. Although that's true for most of the species, sometimes there are added illustrations. For example, here's a bonus feature in the wigeon section:
* Extremely thorough, with plates AND species account text. You gotta see it to believe it.
* Maps up front with plates (it's a minor point but it works for me)
* Hybrids (plates after plates after plates of hybrids, more than I've seen in other books!)
* Range maps are too simplistic (to be fair, I'm sure distribution wasn't the driving force of this book)
* I'd like to have seen more photos in the species accounts to really round it out. At this point, they help but they're not as in-depth as the plates are.
In the end, I DO think this is a valuable addition to your reference material. The amount of information in this book is actually quite impressive when you flip through it; it's more than enough detail for a lifetime of waterfowl perusal. I know that personally, if I had a question about some nitty-gritty detail of a duck/goose, I'd turn to this book first.
I received a complementary copy from the publisher for review purposes,
but the viewpoint expressed in this article is entirely my own.